Healthy sugar alternatives for tea and coffee
Quick answer: If you take two cups of sweet tea or coffee a day, what you stir in adds up over a year. Here is how the common options compare, spoon for spoon.
Key points
- A tablespoon of sugar has about 12 g of sugars; honey has about 17 g.
- Stevia has no sugars or calories but adds nothing else.
- Prebiotic fibre syrup is lightly sweet with 1.6 g of sugars and 14.3 g of fibre per tablespoon.
The comparison
| Per tablespoon | Calories | Sugars | Fibre |
|---|---|---|---|
| White sugar | about 48 | about 12 g | 0 g |
| Honey | about 64 | about 17 g | 0 g |
| Stevia drops | 0 | 0 g | 0 g |
| Sanofysi Prebiotic Syrup | 35 | 1.6 g | 14.3 g |
Sugar and honey figures are typical values. Prebiotic Syrup figures are from its supplement facts panel.
White sugar
Familiar, cheap and reliably sweet. It provides energy and nothing else. Health bodies advise keeping added sugars low, and sweet drinks are one of the easiest places to cut back.
Honey
Honey has flavour and a natural image, but it is still mostly sugars, and spoon for spoon it has more of them than white sugar because it is denser.
Stevia
Stevia is a plant-based sweetener many times sweeter than sugar, so a few drops are enough. It has no calories or sugars. Some people notice an aftertaste, and it brings no fibre or other nutrients.
Prebiotic fibre syrup
A fibre syrup such as Sanofysi Prebiotic Syrup is made from FOS, a soluble plant fibre that tastes mildly sweet. It is less sweet than sugar, so it suits people who want to take the edge off a drink without making it sugary. The difference is what else you get: 14.3 g of prebiotic fibre in the same spoon.
Which should you choose?
- You want maximum sweetness, no calories: stevia.
- You want flavour and don't mind the sugars: honey, in small amounts.
- You want a little sweetness and more fibre: prebiotic syrup.
Many people combine them: half the usual sugar plus a spoon of fibre syrup, then less sugar over time as their taste adjusts.
A note on fibre syrups
Because a tablespoon carries a lot of fibre, start with a teaspoon and build up. If you manage your blood sugar or have a medical condition, speak to a health professional about which sweetener is right for you.
What a year of sweet tea adds up to
Two cups a day with two teaspoons of sugar in each is four teaspoons, or about 16 g of sugar, a day. Over a year that is close to 6 kg of sugar from tea alone.
Halving the sugar and making up the sweetness with a fibre syrup removes about 3 kg of sugar a year without giving up the cup. The World Health Organization advises keeping free sugars below 10% of daily energy, and suggests that below 5% is better still.
Common questions
- What is the healthiest sugar substitute for tea and coffee?
- It depends on what you want. Stevia adds sweetness with no sugars or calories. A prebiotic fibre syrup adds mild sweetness with very little sugar and a large amount of fibre.
- Is honey better than sugar in tea?
- Honey has more flavour and trace compounds, but it is still mostly sugars. A tablespoon of honey has about 17 g of sugars, more than a tablespoon of white sugar.
- Are fructooligosaccharides (FOS) the same as sugar?
- No. FOS is a soluble fibre, not a sugar. Your body does not digest it the way it digests sugar, which is why a tablespoon of FOS syrup has 35 calories and 1.6 g of sugars compared with about 48 calories and 12 g of sugars in white sugar.
Sources
Fibre, the easy way
Sanofysi Prebiotic Syrup gives you 14.3 g of prebiotic fibre in one lightly sweet 15 mL spoon. Stir it into tea, coffee or breakfast.
Shop Prebiotic Syrup